|
|

(On Matthew 8:11)
"To lie down with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, in the kingdom of heaven, doth
not signify to enjoy everlasting happiness in heaven with them, but only to
become the sons of Abraham through faith, Gal. iii. 7, and so to be blessed
with faithful Abraham, ver. 9, to have the blessing of Abraham coming on
them, that they may receive the promise of the spirit, ver. 14, through
faith in Christ to be the seed of Abraham and heirs, according to the
promise, ver. 29, viz. the promise made to Abraham, Gen. xii. 3, renewed to
Isaac, Gen. xxvi. 4, and confirmed to Jacob, Gen. xxviii. 14, and to be,
according to Isaac, the children of promise, Gal. iv. 28. This, says Christ,
shall be the blessing of the believing Gentiles ; they shall be eons of
Abraham, and heirs of the promises made to the patriarchs, and mentioned by
all the holy prophets of the Old Testament ; whereas, the unbelieving Jews,
wanting the faith of Abraham, shall be deprived of the blessings promised to
his seed; for they who seek to enter, and shall not be able, because the
Master has shut to his door, Luke xiii. 24, 25, are those Jews who sought
for
righteousness by the works of the law and not by faith, and therefore found
it not, Rom. ix. 31, 32 ; vi. 7 ; who entered not into the rest prepared for
them, by reason of their unbelief, Heb. iii. 18, 19 ; iv. 2, 5, 8 ; from
whom the kingdom of God was taken away, Matt. xxi. 43 ; they are they who
shall say to Christ, "we have eaten and drunk before thee, and thou hast
taught in our streets," Luke xiii. 26, which could be said only by the
Jews." (Com. in loc. )
(On Matthew 10:22)
"And ye also shall be hated of all the men of the world for my name's sake ;
but he that endureth to the end of these persecutions from the unbelieving
Jews shall be saved from the dreadful destruction coming on them. But when
they persecute you in this city, i. e. in any one city, flee ye into
another; for verily I say unto you, ye shall not have gone over the cities
of Israel till the son of man be come with his Roman army to destroy that
nation, and to burn up their cities." (Par. in loc.)
(On Matthew 16:18)
"That sheol throughout the Old Testament, and hades in the Septuagint,
answering to it, signify not the place of punishment, or of the souls of bad
men only, but the grave only, or the place of death, appears, 1st, From the
root of it, shoal, which signifies to ask, crave, and require, because it
craves for all mea, Prov. xxx. 16, and will let no man escape its hands, Ps.
Ixxxix. 48, it is that sheol or hades, whither we are all going, Eccles. ix.
10. The Hebrew sheol, saith Buxtorf, signifies in general the place of human
bodies, when they are separated from their souls. The Greeks say, that hades
is the place of the dead, saith Dr. Windet: it is o taphos, o tumbos, the
tomb or sepulchre, saith Phavorinus. Thus, to go to the gates of hades, in
Homer, is, saith the Scholiast, periphrasis thanatou, a description of
deatli. He shall knock at the gates of hades, saith Theocritus : toutesti
apothaneitai, he shall die, saith the Scholiast. See the note on Matt. xvi.
18.
2ndly, Because it is the place to which the good as well
as the bad go, for they whose souls go upwards, descend into it; thither
went Jacob, Gen. xxxvii. 35 ; there Job desired to be, chap. xiv. 13, for he
knew that sheol was his house, chap. xvii. 13, and that to descend into the
dust, was to descend into hades, where Olympiodorus brings him in speaking
thus ; is not death common to all men ? is not hades the house of all men ?
Hezeki- ah expected to be there after he went hence, for he said, I shall go
to the gates of hades, Isa. xxxviii. 30,
that is, saith Jerome ' to those gates of which the Psalmist speaks, saying,
Thou will lift me up from the gates of death. The ancient Greeks assigned
one hades to all that died, and therefore say, pantas omou thnetous hades
dechetai. Hades receives all mortal men together ; eis koinon haden panics
exonsin brotoi, all men shall go to hades. , '
3dly, Had the penmen of the Old Testament meant by hades
any receptacle of souls, they could not truly have declared there was no
wisdom or knowledge in sheol, Eccles ix. 10, no remembrance of God there,
Ps. vi. 6, no praising him in sheol, Isa. xxxviii. 18, for those heathen who
looked upon it as the receptacle of souls, held it to be a place in which
they would be punished or rewarded.' Annot. in Acts ii. 27. '
The Hebrew sheol, and the Greek hades, which answers to
it, in the translation of the Seventy, doth signify both in the Scriptures,
the Jewish writers, and the ancient fathers, and more ancient heathens, the
place and receptacle of the dead. Haden nekron chorion, ex- ponunt Greci,
saith the learned Windate, — the Greeks call the place of the dead, hades.
Haides o laphos, hades is the sepulchre, saith Hesychius. By sheol is not
meant the place of the damned spirits, saith Mr. Ainsworth, but of all that
go out of the world; whence in the Chaldee paraphrase it is styled the house
of the grave or the place of burial. Accordingly the ancient Greeks assigned
one hades to all that died, whence they so often say, all that die are in
hades; all men shall go to hades. En hadon sunechontai psuchai, dikaion ie
kai adikon, both just and unjust go to hades, saith Caius, a Roman
presbyter." (Annot. in Matt. xvi. 18.)
(On Matthew 22:7)
"The doctrine of the kingdom of heaven, preached to this nation, is like to
find a success answerable unto that of a certain king who made a marriage
for his son, and sent forth his servants to call them who were to be bidden
to the wedding, viz., the apostles, and the seventy sent to the lost sheep
of the house of Israel, Matt. x. 6, Luke x. 1, and being thus lovingly
invited, they would not come. Wherefore he again sent forth other servants,
viz., the apostles and the hundred and eight on whom the Holy Ghost fell,
saying, Tell them that were bidden, behold I have prepared my dinner, my
oxen and my fatlings are killed, and all things are ready ; come, I pray
you, to the marriage feast; But they made light of it, the invitation, and
went their way, one to his farm, another to his merchandise. And the remnant
of them took his servants, and entreated them spitefully, and slew some of
them. But when the king heard thereof, he was wroth, and he sent forth his
armies and destroyed those murderers, and burnt up their city ; and so will
this spiritual king deal with those of this nation who not only refuse his
invitation to partake of the blessings of the gospel, but also kill his
messengers: he by the Roman army will destroy them, and their capital city.
Then saith he to his servants, the wedding feast is ready, but they who were
bidden were not worthy, and therefore shall not taste of this feast. Go ye
therefore into the highways, to the dispersion of the Jews, and to the
Gentiles, and as many as ye shall find, bid to the marriage. So these
servants went out into the highways, and gathered
together all, as many as they found, both bad and good, and the wedding was
furnished with guests, and when the king came in to see the guests, he saw
there a man which had not on a wedding garment, i. e., a faith and
conversation answerable to the design of the gospel. And he saith to him,
Friend, how camest thou in hither, not having a wedding garment ? And he was
as one speechless. Then said the king to his servants, bind him hand and
foot, and take him away, and cast him into utter darkness ; there shall be
weeping and gnashing of teeth : so shall it be with the Jews, the children
of the kingdom, Matt. viii. 12, Luke xiii. 28. For many of the Jews are
called, hut few of them are chosen ; i. e., believers in the gospel. See
note on 1 Peter, ii. 9." (Par. in loc.)
(On Matthew 23:39)
"These words, by the connexion of them with the former, thus, behold your
house is left unto you desolate, for I say, &c., seem manifestly to relate
to the time of the destruction of the Jews, and to bear this sense : You who
have now with so much indignation heard the children and people saluting me
thus, Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord, after a while shall
lie under so great calamities for the punishment of your infidelity, that
you would be glad of a deliverer to whom you might say these words. This may
also be gathered from the word api arti, after a while; for after Christ's
ascension they saw him not, till he came to the destruction of Jerusalem,
which in the following chapter is so often styled the time of the coming of
the Son of man ; the time when ap' arti, after a while, they should see the
Son of man coming in the clouds, Matt. xxvi. 64." (Annot. in loc.)
(On Matthew 24:12)
"And ye shall be hated of all sorts of men for my name's sake, but yet
possess your souls in patience, Luke xxj. 19; for they that shall endure to
the end, the same shall be saved out of this calamity. But when ye shall see
the abomination of desolation, spoken of by Daniel the prophet, (chap. ix.
27,) standing where it ought not, i. e., the Roman army compassing
Jerusalem, Luke xxi. 20, let him that readeth understand that her desolation
draweth near ; and then let them that be in Judea flee into the mountains of
Perea." (Par. in Mark xiii. 13, 14. )
(On Matthew 24:42)
"This, by Dr. Hammond, seems to be well referred to the especial providence
of God, discernable in those times, in rescuing some, who seemed equally
exposed to danger, from the destruction which shall fall on others ; for
that it relates not to the final judgment, but to the time of the
destruction of the Jews by the Roman army, is evident from the same words
recorded by St. Luke, chap. xvii. 35, 36. For there, the disciples ask their
Lord, where shall this be ? and Christ answers, ver. 37, that where the
carcase (i. e., the Jews,) are, there will the eagles (i. e., the Roman
army, whose ensign was the eagle,) be gathered together. And hence it is
also evident, that the following words being connected to these by the
copulative oun, thus, watch therefore, must refer to the same subject." (Annot.
in loc.)
(On Matthew 24:45)
"Who therefore is that faithful and wise servant, &c., i. e., the servant
who continues constant in the service of his Lord, under all the
persecutions and abounding iniquities of those times, he shall make him
ruler over all his goods; i. e., shall greatly reward his faithfulness, as
this phrase signifies, chap. xxv. 21, 23; for that this phrase cannot import
his advancement to the highest dignities in the church, is evident from
this, that then all that continued faithful to Christ, in those times of
trial, must have been made Bishops. The evil servant here mentioned seems to
be the apostatizing Jew, who, having deserted the faith himself, was
instrumental to smite his fellow-servants, and to betray them to the enemies
of Christianity, as our Lord foretold it would be, Matt. x. 21, xxiv. 10.
And that which induced them thus to apostatize, was this very imagination,
that our Lord delayed his coming, to deliver them, and execute the judgments
here foretold, 2 Pet. iii. 4 ; whence the apostles encourage them to
perseverance, by saying, It is but yet a little while, and he that cometh
will come, and will not tarry, Heb. x. 27, and that the Judge stands at the
door, Jas. v. 9, and the coming of the Lord draweth nigh, ver. 8. And shall
cut him asunder: This was the punishment inflicted by Samuel on Agag, the
enemy of God's people, 1 Sam. xv. 33, and by David on the Ammonites, 2 Sam.
xii. 31, and by Trajan, the Roman Emperor, on the rebellious Jews. It was by
Nebuchadnezzar threatened to the blasphemers of the true God, Dan. iii. 29,
and by young Daniel, to the false accusers of Susanna, ver. 55, 59. It was
used of old, to those who were false to their creditors, saith Tertullian;
to rebels, and betrayers of their country, and that not only in the east,
but among the Romans, as we learn from Suetonius, in the life of Caius; from
Horace, and from Dio; and by the Greeks, as we learn from Homer, from
Sophocles, and from Aristophanes; and in Egypt, as we learn from Herodotus.
And therefore this punishment, saith Christ, will I inflict on those who are
perfidious in their covenant of baptism, and enemies to my government." (Annot.
in loc.)
(On Matthew 25:14)
"Of this parable, as it respects the master travelling into a far country,
and the servants to whom the talents were delivered, see note on Luke xix.
12, where it is also proved that it relates to the Jewish nation, and
therefore is here mentioned after Christ's prediction of the dreadful
judgments which should befal that nation, for murdering their Messiah, and
not improving the day of their visitation." (Annot. in loc.)
"The parable here, as it respects
our Lord Christ going into afar country to receive a kingdom, and return
again, either respects his going to heaven to sit down at the right hand of
God in majesty and glory, and so take possession of his mediatory kingdom,
and the return to punish the unbelieving and obdurate Jews ; or going by his
apostles and disciples to erect a kingdom among the Gentiles, and then
coming, as it were, back to punish the Jews, according to these words of
his, the gospel of the kingdom shall be preached throughout the world for a
testimony to all nations, and then shall the end (of the Jewish polity)
come. Matt. xxiv. 14. ' This parable doth certainly respect the Jewish
nation, as appears, (1.) Because they are here said to reject Christ's
kingdom, saying, we will not have this man to reign over us ; and upon this
account are styled his enemies, and devoted to destruction by him, which
agrees still only to the Jews, ver. 27. (2.) To them is threatened the
punishment of the unprofitable servants, to wit, to be cast out into utter
darkness, &c., Matt. viii. 12 ; xxii. 13 ; Luke xiii. 28 ; Matt. xxv. 30. In
fine, it is expressly said, he therefore spake this parable to them, because
they thought the kingdom of God should immediately appear, vs. 11 and 12." (Annot.
in Luke, xix. 12.)
(On Luke 13:3)
"I tell you nay ; but except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish,
for the same cause, and many of you after the same manner." Ye shall
likewise perish: That is, says Grotius, among the ruins of the city, of
which that tower was a part, they perishing in Jerusalem, verse 4, or rather
among the ruins of the towers of the city, and the temple." (Par. and Note
in loc.)
(On Romans 9:22)
"What injustice, therefore, is it, in God, to deal with you as he dealt with
an hardened Pharaoh, you having as oft refused to hearken to his voice, as
Pharaoh did 'I Or, what if he long hath, and still at present bears with,
such vessels of wrath, filted for destruction, till in a more illustrious
manner, and with more signal marks of his displeasure, for thus rejecting
the gospel and the promised Messiah, he swallow up their nation, their
people, their temple, and their holy city, in one general destruction ? Is
it not for the glory of the divine power and wisdom, to reserve the
rejectors of the Messiah sent to bless them, and the persecutors of the
Christian faith, to be at last cut off with such a remarkable destruction,
as shall render it visible to the world, that God's indignation is incensed
against them for this sin, and so shall give to Jew and Gentile a farther
motive to believe in Jesus ?" (Annot. in loc.)
(On 1 Thessalonians 2:16)
"Our Lord had said to them, fill ye up the measure of your fathers, by
adding to the murder of the prophets, the murder of me, and of those
prophets and wise men I shall send to you, Matt. xxiii. 32—35, that upon you
of this generation may come all the blood shed from Abel to this present
time, Luke xi. 49, 51. This prediction, saith the apostle, is now fulfilled
; and they, by fulfilling it, have filled up the measure of their sins; and
God's wrath is so incensed against them, that it will now destroy their
church and nation to the uttermost; so that it shall not be now as formerly,
when they were sometimes in bondage, and again in freedom from their enemies
— sometimes were captives, and then returned again, after seventy years, to
their own land, found God for awhile angry, and anon, reconciled to them.
But this wrath shall now remain upon them to the uttermost, till the times
of the Gentiles are come in, Luke xxi. 24. See note on Kom. xi. 25. Or, till
they be consumed: — so the phrase is used often in the Old Testament, as
Num. xvii. 13 ; Josh. viii. 24 ; x. 20 ; i. e., God's wrath hath begun to
fall upon them, and they will still continue under it, till they be consumed
by it." (Annot. in loc.)
(On 2 Thessalonians 2:3)
"The son of perdition: this also perfectly agrees to the Jews, not only
because Christ was to smite them with the breath of his mouth, see note on
ver. 8, and to smite the land with a curse, Mai. iv. 6, but because they are
set forth as vessels of wrath, fitted for destruction, Rom. ix. 22, as men
appointed to wrath, 1 Thess. v. 9, to sudden destruction, ver. 4, as men
whose end is destruction, Phil. iii. 19. Note also that this agrees exactly
to the great whore, who is to go into destruction, Rev. xvii. 8, 11." (Annot.
in loc.)
(On Hebrews 10:25)
"The day approaching, (ver. 25.;) i. e., the day of the Lord's coming to
destroy the unbelieving Jews, and to execute his vengeance on them, for
rejecting and crucifying their Messiah, styled by St. Luke, the days of
vengeance, chap. xxi. 22. The day of the Lord's coming which who can bear ?
saith the prophet, Mai. iii. 2 ; the day burning like an oven ; the-day
coming that shall so burn up them that do wickedly, as not to leave them
root or branch, Mai. iv. 1 ; the day of the Lord drawing near, when all the
inhabitants of the land shall tremble, Joel ii. 1 ; the great and terrible
day of the Lord, vs. 11, 31, the day of the Son of Man. That this is the
meaning of the place, will appear from the scope of the apostle, which is to
terrify them he writes to, by the consideration of that dreadful day of
vengeance threatened to the unbelieving Jews, not only by our Lord, but
their own prophets, and now near at hand; as it follows from ver 26, to ver.
31." (Annot. in loc.)
(On James 2:13)
"For he shall have judgment without mercy, who hath showed no mercy, and so
hath highly thwarted the great law of love; and mercy rejoiceth against, or
triumpheth over judgment, i. e., enables the man to rejoice, as being free
from the judgment of condemnation from that God, who, to the merciful, will
show himself merciful, Psalm xviii. 27. ' Of this mercy, the Jews were so
unmindful, that Josephus having said, they violated the laws of nature, and
polluted the divinity with their injustice towards men, he adds, that no
good affection was so entirely lost among men, as that of mercy." (Par. and
Annot. in loc.)
(On 1 Peter 4:17)
"For the time is come, that judgment must, according to our Lord's
prediction — Matt. xxiv. 21, 22; Mark xiii. 13; Luke xxi. 16, If—begin at
the house of God ; and if it first begin at us — believing Jews, what will
be the end of them that obey not the gospel of God'( And if some of the
righteous scarcely be saved, i. e., preserved from this burning, ver. 12,
being saved, yet so as by fire, 1 Cor. iii. 15— where shall the ungodly and
the sinner appear in safety from these dreadful judgments which are coming
on the Jewish nation ? Prov. xi. 31." (Annot. in loc.)
(2 Peter 3 is not about the Destruction of Jerusalem)
"And that it is not true, has been shewn by Michaelis, from the following
considerations. First, St. Peter represents the fact for which he argues, as
possible, by appealing to the deluge. Now no man would appeal to the deluge,
to shew the possibility that a city may be taken and destroyed: but we may
very properly argue, that, as the earth has already undergone a material
change, so it may undergo another change equally great. And what St. Peter
says is consonant to the Jewish theology, in which was taught the doctrine,
that the earth was destined to suffer two grand revolutions, the one
effected by water, the other to be effected by fire. See Joseph. Ant. 1.
iii. 3. Secondly, no one could doubt that Jerusalem would be destroyed
merely because the destruction was delayed longer than he expected, and
still less because all things continued as they were from the beginning of
the creation. This ground of doubt manifestly implies, that the question
related to a revolution of the earth. Thirdly, we know of no heretics who
called in question Christ's prediction of the destruction of Jerusalem. And,
even if there were such, it is hardly credible that St. Peter should write
an epistle to persons who were bom heathens, and lived in the northern part
of Asia Minor, to prove an event with which they had little or no concern.
Fourthly, what St. Peter says, ch. iii. 8, that' One day is with the Lord as
a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day,' is not very applicable
to an event which was to take place within six or seven years after St.
Peter wrote. Lastly, if we explain what St. Peter says, as relating to the
destruction of Jerusalem, we must take his expressions in a figurative
sense; but figurative language, though it is well adapted to prophecy, such
as that which is recorded Matt, xiv, is not very suitable to a plain
doctrinal dissertation, especially to one delivered in the form of an
epistle." (II Peter Introduction, vol. iv. p. 357.)
WHAT OTHERS HAVE SAID

N. Nisbett
Henry Alford
"16.On the other hand, some have regarded the prophecy as one already
fulfilled. So
Grotius, Wetstein, Le Clerc, Whitby, Schöttgen, Nösselt, Krause, and
Harduin. All these concur in referring the "advent of the Lord"
to the coming of Christ in the destruction of Jerusalem".
21. Whitby takes the
Jewish people for Antichrist, and finds in the apostasy the falling
away of the Jewish converts to their old Judaism, alluded to in the
Epistle to the Hebrews (iii. 12-14 ; iv. 11 ; vi. 4-6 ; x. 26,27 al. fr.).
His "hinderer" is "the Emperor Claudius, who will let till he
be taken away, i.e. he will hinder the Jews from breaking out into an open
rebellion in his time, they being so signally and particularly obliged by
him, that they cannot for shame think of revolting from his government."
"All these preterist
interpretations have against them one fatal objections :- that it is
impossible to conceive of the destruction of Jerusalem as in any sense
corresponding to the Lord's coming, in St. Paul's sense of the term : see
especially, as bearing immediately on this passage, 1 Thess. ii. 19; iii. 13
; iv. 15 ; v. 23." (The New Testament for English Readers,
First Thessalonians, Introduction, p 86)
William
Whiston
"Dr. Whitby well observes, no small part of the evidence for the truth of
the Christian religion does depend upon the 'completions' of the prophecies,
and it is believed 'Josephus' history' furnishes a record of 'their
exact completions' " (pg. 589)
Daniel Whitby (1638-1726) was an English theologian. An Arminian minister in
the Church of England, Whitby was known for being strongly anti-Calvinistic
and later gave evidence of strong Arian and Unitarian tendencies. In 1710 he
had written his Discourse on the Five Points [of Calvinism] which eventually
drew Calvinist responses from English Baptist John Gill in his The Cause of
God and Truth (1735) and American Congregationalist Jonathan Edwards in his
Freedom of the Will (1754).
Whitby is considered by many to be the one who systemetized
postmillennialism although seeds of this millennialist belief were sown long
before with persons such as Augustine. Although Whitby may have been an
Arminian minister, postmillennialism is now commonly associated with
Calvinist and Covenental churches, specifically Reconstructionist churches.
What do YOU think ?
Send an email with your comments to
todd @ preteristarchive.com
Be sure to include the article name.
They will be posted shortly
upon receipt
|